If anything stands out from the many guesthouses I've stayed at during this road trip, it's the delicious dinner buffet! The staff were friendly and the room was cozy and nice. My only complaint is that my room was right next to the outdoor hot tub, so I could hear people chatting and soaking well past midnight.
A clean, no frills place. Beds were comfortable, shower was hot, and the dogs were friendly. Very close to Selfoss which has some great places to eat. Perfect as a place to stop and rest for the night.